```json
{
  "clip_9": {
    "overall_movement_yield": 3,
    "motion_quality": "CHAOTIC",
    "camera_move_type": "none (push-in not realized)",
    "coherence": 3,
    "warping_or_melting": "yes — prompt asked for push-in with strong parallax and foreground rocks sliding past the lens; objective global dx -1 dy +4 means essentially no translation was detected. Energy 1506 with active 0.242 is consistent with local boiling/flicker rather than a dolly. Expect the monolith to shimmer or breathe in place rather than grow in frame.",
    "viewer_verdict": "broken and noisy (or at best 'static with shimmer')"
  },
  "clip_10": {
    "overall_movement_yield": 4,
    "motion_quality": "CHAOTIC",
    "camera_move_type": "none / weak drift (orbit not realized)",
    "coherence": 4,
    "warping_or_melting": "yes — an arcing orbit should produce large, smooth, coherent global displacement; measured dx -3 dy -1 is negligible. Energy 1798 / active 0.354 is the second-highest raw motion, but it is not organized into a rotational sweep. Likely parallax layers sliding independently and geometry warping instead of a rigid camera arc.",
    "viewer_verdict": "broken and noisy"
  },
  "clip_11": {
    "overall_movement_yield": 2,
    "motion_quality": "CHAOTIC",
    "camera_move_type": "shake (numerically only — no net translation)",
    "coherence": 2,
    "warping_or_melting": "yes — highest energy (3557) and highest active fraction (0.578) with global dx +1 dy -1, i.e. zero net displacement. This is the signature of per-frame high-frequency churn: boiling textures, flickering fissure, jittering rocks, edge smearing. Shake is a plausible excuse for low net translation, but shake should still show bounded oscillation, not near-zero aggregate drift with maximal pixel delta. Most likely the model is regenerating detail every frame rather than moving a camera.",
    "viewer_verdict": "broken and noisy"
  },
  "clip_12": {
    "overall_movement_yield": 7,
    "motion_quality": "COHERENT",
    "camera_move_type": "pan (whip pan, realized)",
    "coherence": 7,
    "warping_or_melting": "partial — global nz 0.851 with dx -30 dy -11 is the only clip showing genuine, large, directional camera displacement, consistent with a whip pan across the canyon. Motion blur streaking is expected and desirable here, so some smear is prompt-intended rather than artifact. Residual risk: fast pans in low-step turbo models can melt background geometry at frame edges; worth spot-checking the cliff/bridge silhouettes for stretching.",
    "viewer_verdict": "dynamic and alive"
  },
  "movement_quality_summary": "Clip 11's top raw energy is artifacting, not movement. Energy and active-pixel fraction measure how much the image changes frame-to-frame, not whether that change is organized; with global dx +1 dy -1 there is no net camera displacement, so the 3557 energy is per-frame churn — boiling, flicker, and warping that a viewer reads as noise. Clip 12 has roughly half the raw energy (1885) but the only real translation (dx -30 dy -11, nz 0.851), which is what a viewer actually perceives as camera motion. For 'maximized movement' as a viewer experience, clip 12 is clearly the better example: coherent directional displacement beats high-amplitude incoherent churn. Clips 9 and 10 sit between — moderate energy with near-zero translation, meaning the prompts' push-in and orbit were not realized and the numbers reflect local instability rather than the requested camera work. Practical implication: raw energy/active fraction is a poor proxy for perceived dynamism in this model; global translation magnitude (dx/dy/nz) is the better discriminator, and the two should be reported together rather than energy alone."
}
```

Note on scope: no files were supplied, so this diagnosis is based solely on the four prompts and the objective metrics given. I have not viewed the videos — the coherence and warping judgments are inferences from the metric pattern (high energy + near-zero global translation ⇒ incoherent churn), not direct observation. If frame-level inspection is available, the specific things to check are: clip 9 for whether the monolith actually grows in frame, clip 10 for rotational parallax consistency, clip 11 for per-frame texture regeneration on the fissure and loose rocks, and clip 12 for edge geometry melting during the pan.