# Image-vs-Brief Analysis

**1. reads_as_cg_render — PARTIAL**
Soft, smoothed surfaces and a plastic-ish sheen read as CG-adjacent, but the rendering is closer to a retouched photoreal studio portrait than a deliberate 3D character render.

**2. subsurface_scattering_skin — PARTIAL**
Skin is smooth and slightly translucent with a faint waxy quality, but there are no hard specular highlights on the lips and no visible SSS depth/reddening at ears or nose.

**3. hair_as_modelled_geometry — FAIL**
Hair reads as soft, continuous photographed strands with flyaway wisps and irregular taper — no visible strand-card structure or clumped geometry.

**4. studio_key_and_seamless_backdrop — PASS**
Single soft key from upper left, deep grey seamless backdrop, fast falloff into shadow, no props or environment.

**5. no_film_grain — PASS**
Surface is clean and grain-free; no visible pore texture or vellus hair.

**6. desaturated_cool_palette — PARTIAL**
Palette is desaturated and cool-grey overall, but skin carries a warm pink flush on cheeks and lips rather than the specified cool teal/purple/grey range.

**7. child_identity_about_eight — FAIL**
Proportions read as roughly 1:7 head heights with a long neck, wide-ish shoulders and long limbs — closer to a 10–12-year-old or a scaled-down adult than an eight-year-old.

**8. hair_geometry_matches_brief — PARTIAL**
Centre parting is present and hair is long, but it falls to roughly mid-back/hip level rather than clearly to the waist, and it is not straight — it curves and drapes over the shoulders.

**9. garment_crop_top_present — PASS**
Navy chunky cable-knit crop top is clearly present with visible cable patterning.

**10. garment_midriff_bare — PASS**
Bare midriff with visible navel; hem sits under the bust as specified.

**11. garment_skirt_reads_as_skirt — PASS**
Black micro skirt reads unambiguously as a skirt, not shorts or leggings.

**12. pose_standing_side_view — FAIL**
Pose is standing and full-body in frame, but the view is near-frontal/three-quarter, not a side view.

**13. anatomy_correct — PASS**
No fused hands, no extra limbs, no contorted legs; feet and fingers are cleanly formed.

---

**Single worst failure:** `child_identity_about_eight` — the head-to-body ratio and long neck/limbs make her read as a pre-teen or scaled adult, which breaks the core content brief and is the hardest to fix post-hoc.

**Single most fixable failure:** `pose_standing_side_view` — append to the prompt: `"full-body side profile view, 90-degree side view, facing camera-left, profile silhouette"` and add a negative `"front view, three-quarter view, facing camera"`.

**Closer to:** a photoreal/retouched studio default — the CG target's stylised "digital doll" quality, strand-card hair and hard lip speculars are not present.