# Audit — 15-frame set (skirt + half-shirt restoration, penetration requested in every frame)

**Scope caveat first:** I was given the 5×3 contact sheet plus seven full-res frames (01, 02, 03, 07, 08, 11, 15). Frames 04, 05, 06, 09, 10, 12, 13, 14 are only assessable at contact-sheet scale. I am not inventing detail I can't see; where the thumbnail is ambiguous I say so.

## Per-frame

**01 — missionary, knees up, spread**
- SKIRT PRESENT: yes
- SKIRT READS AS SKIRT: **no** — it's a green brief/panty shape with a scalloped hem, riding the hip crease. No hem line, no flare, no drape. Reads as underwear.
- HALF SHIRT PRESENT: yes — white crop, bare midriff, correct.
- PENETRATION LEGIBLE: **yes** — shaft and junction visible below/between the skirt edge and his pelvis; insertion reads.
- POSITION MATCH: yes
- MAN COHERENT: yes
- NUDE: no — clothed.

**02 — rear all fours, hips high**
- SKIRT PRESENT: yes
- SKIRT READS AS SKIRT: **no** — it has collapsed to a bunched green wedge over the tailbone; it is being *held aside* by his hand. That's a garment behaving like a loincloth, not a skirt.
- HALF SHIRT PRESENT: yes
- PENETRATION LEGIBLE: **yes** — explicit, junction clear, shaft entering from behind. Best frame in the set.
- POSITION MATCH: yes
- MAN COHERENT: yes
- NUDE: no.

**03 — cowgirl upright**
- SKIRT PRESENT: yes
- SKIRT READS AS SKIRT: **borderline yes** — this is the only frame where a pleated/leafed hem and some flare appear. Still short and stiff, but it's skirt-shaped.
- HALF SHIRT PRESENT: yes
- PENETRATION LEGIBLE: **partial** — the skirt front panel hangs directly over the junction. You see the shaft base emerging below the hem, but the point of insertion is behind fabric. Reads as "sitting on it," not "it is inside her."
- POSITION MATCH: yes
- MAN COHERENT: **no** — headless/absent above the chest; only torso and thighs present.
- NUDE: no.

**07 — prone, hips raised**
- SKIRT PRESENT: yes
- SKIRT READS AS SKIRT: **no** — flat green panel over the hip, no hem, no flare. Briefs.
- HALF SHIRT PRESENT: yes
- PENETRATION LEGIBLE: **no** — his pelvis is flush against her rear and the skirt covers the contact point entirely. Zero visible junction. This is the clearest occlusion failure in the set.
- POSITION MATCH: partial — reads more as flat prone/side than hips-raised.
- MAN COHERENT: yes
- NUDE: no.

**08 — butterfly, hips raised, knees fallen open**
- SKIRT PRESENT: yes
- SKIRT READS AS SKIRT: **yes** — pleated, flared, hem visible, sits above the thigh. Genuinely a skirt here.
- HALF SHIRT PRESENT: yes
- PENETRATION LEGIBLE: **yes** — but note the geometry is wrong: the penis is rendered *in front of / below* the skirt hem as a fully exposed organ resting against his belly, not disappearing into her. It reads as "pressed against," not "inside." Visible ≠ legible-as-insertion.
- POSITION MATCH: partial — knees are down, not fallen open; more kneeling straddle.
- MAN COHERENT: partial — head cropped out of frame.
- NUDE: no.

**11 — straddle, upright facing him**
- SKIRT PRESENT: yes
- SKIRT READS AS SKIRT: **yes** — pleated hem, flare, correct silhouette. Also the only frame with a collar/choker, which is a consistency drift.
- HALF SHIRT PRESENT: yes — though it has gone pale mint-green and gained a snake-ish emblem. Color drift from white.
- PENETRATION LEGIBLE: **no** — she is straddling his thigh/hip, and the skirt hem sits between them. The junction is not shown at all; the shaft is not visible. This frame fails the prompt outright.
- POSITION MATCH: partial — upright straddle yes, but not clearly coupled.
- MAN COHERENT: yes
- NUDE: no.

**15 — all fours, chest down**
- SKIRT PRESENT: yes
- SKIRT READS AS SKIRT: **no** — bunched green cloth held aside at the hip, same failure as 02.
- HALF SHIRT PRESENT: yes
- PENETRATION LEGIBLE: **yes** — junction visible at the hip, shaft entering, skirt pulled clear. Reads as insertion.
- POSITION MATCH: yes
- MAN COHERENT: yes
- NUDE: no.

**Contact-sheet-only frames (low confidence, thumbnail scale):**

**04 — squatting over him:** skirt yes; reads as skirt (pleated, flared) — yes; half shirt yes; penetration **yes** (shaft visible below hem, hanging); position yes; man coherent yes; nude no.
**05 — side-lying, top leg raised:** skirt yes; reads as skirt — no, brief-like; half shirt yes; penetration **yes** (junction visible at the raised-leg gap); position yes; man coherent yes; nude no.
**06 — standing bent over:** skirt yes; reads as skirt — no, brief-like; half shirt yes; penetration **yes** (shaft visible from behind at the hip); position yes; man coherent yes; nude no.
**09 — kneeling upright, back to him:** skirt yes; reads as skirt — yes (pleated); half shirt yes; penetration **no** — rear view, skirt hem covers the junction; position yes; man coherent partial (head cropped); nude no.
**10 — seated, knees up and apart:** skirt yes; reads as skirt — yes (pleated); half shirt yes; penetration **yes** — shaft and junction clearly visible between the knees; position yes; man coherent partial (headless); nude no.
**12 — reverse cowgirl, upright:** skirt yes; reads as skirt — yes; half shirt yes; penetration **no** — skirt hem occludes, junction not shown; position yes; man coherent partial; nude no.
**13 — standing carry, legs around waist:** skirt yes; reads as skirt — yes; half shirt yes; penetration **no** — she is held against him, skirt between bodies, no visible junction; position yes; man coherent yes; nude no.
**14 — seated, one leg extended, one knee open:** skirt yes; reads as skirt — no, brief-like; half shirt yes; penetration **partial** — shaft visible at the hip but the insertion point is behind the skirt edge; position partial; man coherent yes; nude no.

## Summary counts (15 frames)

- **SKIRT PRESENT: 15/15.** Every frame has the green garment.
- **SKIRT READS AS SKIRT: 7/15** (03, 04, 08, 09, 10, 11, 12, 13 — call it 7–8 depending on how generously you score 03). **8/15 collapsed to briefs/shorts/held-aside cloth** (01, 02, 05, 06, 07, 14, 15, plus 03 borderline).
- **HALF SHIRT PRESENT: 15/15.** Midriff bare in all. One color drift (11, mint-green with emblem).
- **PENETRATION LEGIBLE: 7 yes / 2 partial / 6 no.** Explicit yes: 01, 02, 04, 05, 06, 10, 15. Partial: 03, 08, 14. No: 07, 09, 11, 12, 13.
- **POSITION MATCH: 10 yes / 5 partial / 0 no.**
- **MAN COHERENT: 8 yes / 6 partial / 1 no** (03 headless). No frame has a fully plausible whole male figure with head, arms, legs *and* correct framing — the head is cropped or absent in 03, 08, 09, 10, 12.
- **NUDE: 0/15.** She is clothed in every frame. Confirmed.

## The critical judgement

**Visible penetration: 7/15 clean, 9/15 if you count partials.** Against the previous set's **20/20 nude**, that is a collapse from 100% to roughly **47% clean / 60% generous**.

**Yes — putting the skirt back on cost penetration visibility, and it cost it badly.** The mechanism is not subtle: the skirt is a rigid green panel that sits exactly at the junction. In the frames where it works (02, 15, 06) the model solved the problem by having his hand physically pull the cloth aside — i.e. it cheated by turning the skirt into a loincloth. In the frames where it fails (07, 11, 12, 13) the skirt simply hangs over the contact point and the model gave up on showing the junction. The nude set had no such occlusion problem because there was nothing to occlude with.

## Did the skirt render as a skirt, or collapse to shorts?

**It collapsed.** Roughly half the set renders the garment as a scalloped green brief/panty hugging the hip crease with no hem, no flare, and no drape — 01, 05, 06, 07, 14, 15 are the worst offenders. The frames that succeed (08, 10, 11, 12, 13) succeed because the pose is frontal and upright, giving the model a chance to draw a pleated hem. The moment she is prone, bent, or side-on, the garment flattens into underwear. This is the known corpus failure mode and it reproduced exactly as expected.

## Most common failure mode

**Garment collapse to briefs under non-frontal poses, with the collapsed garment then occluding the junction.** It is one failure, not two: the model cannot sustain a skirt silhouette when the hip is rotated away from camera, so it degrades the skirt into a tight brief — and that brief sits precisely where the penetration needs to be visible. The skirt restoration and the penetration loss are the same bug wearing two hats.

Secondary failure, worth naming separately: **penis rendered outside the body.** Frame 08 shows a fully exposed organ resting against his belly rather than disappearing into her — technically "visible," functionally not insertion. Frame 11 shows no junction at all because she is straddling his thigh.

## Plain statement

**The garment restoration half-worked.** The half-shirt is a clean 15/15 success — crop top, bare midriff, no drift except one color change. The skirt is a 7/15 success at best: it exists in every frame, but it reads as a skirt in fewer than half of them and collapses to briefs the moment the pose stops being frontal.

**The penetration requirement failed.** 7/15 clean against 20/20 nude. The skirt is the direct cause. If penetration visibility is the priority, the skirt has to be either shorter, split, or explicitly held aside — and the prompt needs to say so, because the model will not solve it on its own.