## Per-frame audit

I can only see clearly: the contact sheet (all 24, small) and eight full-resolution frames. The eight full-res frames map to contact-sheet cells by content — I identify them as **06, 07, 08, 09, 14, 17, 18, 23** (the sheet's row 1 col 6, row 2 col 1, row 2 col 2, row 2 col 3, row 3 col 2, row 3 col 5, row 4 col 1, row 4 col 5). If that mapping is wrong, the per-frame lines below are wrong; the summary axes are not.

**Full-resolution frames (high confidence):**

- **06** — POSITION MATCH: **partial**. Legs are up and spread, but she is *seated upright* on him, not supine with hips on the floor; the "legs lifted clear of floor" reads as a straddle, not a supine lift. HANDS HOLDING: **yes** (both hands on her hips/thighs). MAN COHERENT: **no** — headless torso slab, no arms above the elbows, no legs. PENETRATION LEGIBLE: **yes**. LIMBS TRACEABLE: **partial** — her legs resolve, his do not exist.
- **07** — POSITION MATCH: **partial**. Seated with knees up and apart, soles flat — but she is sitting *on his lap*, not on a seat, and his hands are on her knee/shin, not gripping both knees. HANDS HOLDING: **yes** (one hand). MAN COHERENT: **no** — head cropped out of frame, torso only, legs merge into an undifferentiated mass. PENETRATION LEGIBLE: **no** — crotch contact is hidden by shorts. LIMBS TRACEABLE: **partial**.
- **08** — POSITION MATCH: **no**. Prompted "back flat against his chest, knees spread over his thighs" — rendered is a *side-seated lean*, her back against his side/shoulder, one knee up, one leg folded under. Not back-to-chest. HANDS HOLDING: **yes** (his hand on her knee). MAN COHERENT: **partial** — head and torso present, but his lower body is a single fused leg-blob with no separable legs. PENETRATION LEGIBLE: **no**. LIMBS TRACEABLE: **no** — her legs and his legs merge at the hip.
- **09** — POSITION MATCH: **partial**. Weight on hip, one knee bent and dropped open — but the *other* leg is also bent, not straight; and she is reclining on him rather than seated upright. HANDS HOLDING: **yes** (hand on bent knee). MAN COHERENT: **partial** — head and chest present, lower body absent/fused. PENETRATION LEGIBLE: **no**. LIMBS TRACEABLE: **partial**.
- **14** — POSITION MATCH: **yes**. All fours, palms flat, arms straight, knees apart, back long and level. Best match in the set. HANDS HOLDING: **yes** (hand on hip/waist). MAN COHERENT: **partial** — head, torso, one arm, one knee visible; his other leg is missing. PENETRATION LEGIBLE: **yes**. LIMBS TRACEABLE: **yes** for her, **partial** for him.
- **17** — POSITION MATCH: **partial**. Standing bent forward at the waist, feet flat — but her torso is *horizontal and lifted*, not folded down with palms on the floor; her arms hang/dangle rather than plant. HANDS HOLDING: **yes** (both hands at her hip/waist). MAN COHERENT: **yes** — full standing figure, head, both legs, both feet. PENETRATION LEGIBLE: **yes**. LIMBS TRACEABLE: **yes**.
- **18** — POSITION MATCH: **no**. Prompted standing on one straight leg with the other thigh horizontal at hip height. Rendered: she is *reclined/suspended*, both legs bent and folded, neither leg straight and planted. HANDS HOLDING: **yes** (hand under her thigh). MAN COHERENT: **partial** — torso and one arm, head cropped, legs not visible as separate limbs. PENETRATION LEGIBLE: **yes**. LIMBS TRACEABLE: **no** — her legs fold into each other and into his arm.
- **23** — POSITION MATCH: **partial**. Side-lying is plausible, but the "lower leg straight / upper leg lifted and bent toward chest" is not cleanly readable — both legs appear bent, and the lifted leg's knee is ambiguous. HANDS HOLDING: **yes** (hand on upper leg). MAN COHERENT: **no** — headless torso, no arms, no legs, floating hands attached to nothing. PENETRATION LEGIBLE: **yes**. LIMBS TRACEABLE: **no**.

**Contact-sheet-only frames (lower confidence, small render):**

- **01** — partial; legs folded up, but not clearly "over her own shoulders"; hands on ankles plausible. Man: torso slab, headless. Penetration: unclear. Limbs: partial.
- **02** — partial; knees bent and spread, but she reads as *seated upright* rather than supine. Hands: yes. Man: slab. Penetration: no. Limbs: partial.
- **03** — yes/partial; knees to chest with feet up, hands near shins. Man: slab, headless. Penetration: no. Limbs: partial.
- **04** — partial; one leg up, one down, but the "folded over his shoulder" is not legible. Hands: yes. Man: slab. Penetration: no. Limbs: partial.
- **05** — partial; knees bent and spread, but no visible pad and she is upright, not supine. Hands: yes. Man: slab. Penetration: no. Limbs: partial.
- **10** — partial; legs folded to one side, but the "weight on right hip, both legs together" is not clean. Hands: yes. Man: slab. Penetration: no. Limbs: partial.
- **11** — partial; prone with hips raised is plausible, but legs are not clearly "straight and together." Hands: yes. Man: partial. Penetration: no. Limbs: partial.
- **12** — partial; prone with knees drawn under is plausible. Hands: yes. Man: partial. Penetration: no. Limbs: partial.
- **13** — partial; prone with one knee out wide is plausible. Hands: yes. Man: partial. Penetration: no. Limbs: partial.
- **15** — partial; forearms-down all-fours is plausible, but "hips highest point" is not clear. Hands: yes. Man: partial. Penetration: no. Limbs: partial.
- **16** — partial; one knee forward is plausible. Hands: yes. Man: partial. Penetration: no. Limbs: partial.
- **19** — partial; wall-standing with one knee up is plausible, but the wall is not visible. Hands: yes. Man: partial. Penetration: no. Limbs: partial.
- **20** — yes/partial; kneeling upright, knees apart. Hands: yes. Man: partial. Penetration: no. Limbs: partial.
- **21** — partial; kneeling leaning back is plausible. Hands: yes. Man: partial. Penetration: no. Limbs: partial.
- **22** — partial; straddling upright, knees spread. Hands: yes. Man: slab. Penetration: yes (visible). Limbs: partial.
- **24** — partial; squatting over him, knees spread. Hands: yes. Man: slab. Penetration: yes. Limbs: partial.

## Summary counts (24 frames)

- **POSITION MATCH**: yes **2** (14, 20) · partial **17** · no **5** (08, 18, and — on the sheet — 02, 05, 22 read as upright-straddle rather than the prompted supine/squat; count those as no if strict).
- **HANDS HOLDING**: yes **24** · no **0**.
- **MAN COHERENT**: yes **1** (17) · partial **~10** · no **~13** (headless slabs, floating hands, fused legs).
- **PENETRATION LEGIBLE**: yes **~6** (06, 14, 17, 18, 22, 23, 24) · no **~18**.
- **LIMBS TRACEABLE**: yes **~2** (14, 17) · partial **~15** · no **~7**.

## Distinctness — the real finding

**Distinct body silhouettes: roughly 6–8, not 24.**

Near-duplicate clusters I can defend from the sheet:

- **01, 02, 03, 04, 05, 06** — all the same "seated/reclined upright, knees up, feet toward camera, hands on legs" silhouette. 02/05/06 are the same shape at slightly different angles. 01 and 03 differ only in ankle position.
- **07, 08, 09, 10** — all the same "side-seated, torso leaning back on him, one knee up, one leg folded" silhouette. 08 and 09 are near-identical; 07 and 10 are the same pose mirrored/rotated.
- **11, 12, 13** — prone variants, genuinely different in leg configuration, but rendered so small and so similarly that they read as one silhouette with three leg tweaks.
- **14, 15, 16** — all-fours variants; 14 and 15 are the same shape (arms down vs forearms down is barely visible), 16 differs only in one knee.
- **17, 18, 19** — standing variants; 17 and 18 are near-duplicates (bent-forward vs reclined-suspended), 19 is the wall version of the same lifted-knee shape.
- **20, 21** — kneeling upright; 21 is 20 with a lean. Near-duplicate.
- **22, 24** — straddle/squat; 22 and 24 are the same silhouette (upright on him, knees spread), differing only in how low the hips sit.
- **23** — side-lying; the only genuinely distinct silhouette in the back half.

**Strict count: ~7 distinct silhouettes** (supine-knees-up, side-seated-lean, prone, all-fours, standing-bent, kneeling, straddle/squat), plus 23 as an outlier. That is 7 shapes distributed across 24 frames.

## Most common failure mode

**The model collapses every prompt into a small library of "girl upright, knees up, hands on her" poses, and renders the man as a headless torso with floating hands.** The position prompt is being overridden by a compositional prior — the model wants her face visible and upright, so supine prompts render as seated, standing prompts render as reclined, and "back flat against his chest" renders as a side lean. Secondary failure: the man is almost never a whole body — no head, no arms above the elbow, no separable legs — which destroys LIMBS TRACEABLE and makes penetration ambiguous in most frames.

**Verdict: this does not read as 24 different positions. It reads as about 7 positions repeated with small leg-angle variations and a camera orbit.** The set is a pose *family*, not a pose *catalogue*.