# Anatomy & Pose Audit — Frames 17–20 (supine) / 21–24 (seated)

**Context gap:** no filenames were supplied, so frames are mapped by image order (1st = 17 … 8th = 24). If the order differs, the table rows shift.

| frame | disembodied_feet | contorted_legs | floating_hands | extra_missing | leg_traceable | man_coherent | pose_matches | cg_style | note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 17 | NO | NO | YES | NO | YES | NO | NO | YES | Man's torso truncated at chest; arms absent, hands unreadable. |
| 18 | NO | YES | NO | NO | NO | YES | NO | YES | Her left leg folds across body; shin angle and hip origin unclear. |
| 19 | NO | NO | NO | NO | YES | YES | NO | YES | Man's arms trace to shoulders; her legs read as kneeling, not supine. |
| 20 | NO | NO | NO | NO | YES | YES | NO | YES | Side view reads kneeling/upright, not supine. |
| 21 | NO | YES | NO | YES | NO | NO | YES | YES | Two girls present; extra figure, overlapping legs untraceable. |
| 22 | NO | NO | NO | NO | YES | NO | YES | YES | Man reduced to a forearm and hand at left edge; torso absent. |
| 23 | NO | NO | NO | NO | YES | YES | YES | YES | Seated family holds; man's arms attach plausibly. |
| 24 | NO | NO | NO | NO | YES | YES | NO | YES | Man is prone beneath her; she is seated but he is not upright. |

## Totals

- **disembodied_feet:** 0 / 8
- **contorted_legs:** 2 / 8
- **floating_hands:** 1 / 8
- **extra_missing:** 1 / 8
- **leg_traceable:** 7 / 8
- **man_coherent:** 4 / 8
- **pose_matches:** 3 / 8
- **cg_style:** 8 / 8

## Diagnosis

The stated fixes largely landed on the **feet** (0/8 disembodied — the original defect appears resolved) and on **leg continuity** (7/8 traceable). The residual failures cluster in two places:

1. **Man coherence (4/8)** — the weak column. Frames 17, 21, 22, 24 crop or occlude the man so severely that his arms/torso cannot be traced to shoulders. Frame 17 is the clearest regression of the exact defect this set was built to fix: hands present, forearms and shoulders absent. The pose clauses name his arms, but the *camera framing* still cuts them off — the fix is compositional, not just descriptive.
2. **Pose family (3/8)** — frames 19, 20, 24 read as kneeling or upright rather than supine. Either the supine clause is being overridden by the seated/kneeling framing, or the frame-to-family mapping in the prompt set is mislabeled. Worth confirming which frames were actually intended as supine before re-rolling.

**Likely required changes (no files supplied, so these are inferences):**
- Add an explicit framing constraint for the man — e.g. "his near shoulder and upper arm are in frame" — for the supine family, since pose text alone is not preventing the crop.
- Re-check the supine clause wording for 19–20; if those frames are meant to be supine, the current phrasing is losing to the kneeling composition.
- Frame 21's extra figure (two girls) is a separate defect class not covered by the eight criteria — flag for a duplicate-subject check.

**Cannot verify:** whether frame numbering matches image order, and whether 19–20 were authored as supine or mislabeled.