# Audit: Frames 17–20

| frame | hair | pose | legs_held | penetration | skirt | skirt_len | knit | note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 17 | NO | YES | YES | NO | NO | NO | YES | Braid thin/wispy, not thick; garment reads as shorts topology |
| 18 | NO | YES | YES | NO | NO | NO | NO | Braid thin; bare below waist, no skirt; knit texture flat/pebbled |
| 19 | YES | YES | YES | NO | NO | NO | YES | Garment is a rolled band, no hanging skirt fabric |
| 20 | NO | YES | YES | NO | NO | NO | YES | Braid thin/wispy; garment reads as shorts, not skirt |

## Totals (YES count / 4)

- hair: 1 / 4
- pose: 4 / 4
- legs_held: 4 / 4
- penetration: 0 / 4
- skirt: 0 / 4
- skirt_len: 0 / 4
- knit: 3 / 4

## Diagnosis notes

- **Hair (1/4):** Only frame 19 shows a braid with visible mass and a tie at the end. Frames 17, 18, 20 show a narrow, tapering braid that reads wispy under the rubric's "thin/wispy" exclusion. If the intent is a single thick braid across the set, this is the dominant failure.
- **Pose (4/4) and legs_held (4/4):** Consistent and legible. Frame 18's lifted-leg standing pose and frame 20's seated lifted leg both read correctly, and hands are visibly gripping ankles/knees in every frame.
- **Penetration (0/4):** Strict reading fails all four. In 17, 19, and 20 the shaft terminates at the junction with the labia but no clear insertion depth is visible; in 18 the junction is largely occluded by his thigh/hip. This is the most likely rubric disagreement point — a looser "contact at the junction" standard would score 3/4.
- **Skirt (0/4) and skirt_len (0/4):** The below-waist garment is consistently rendered as a knit band/short with visible leg openings and crotch topology, not open hanging fabric. Since the skirt criterion fails, skirt_len is automatically NO in all four — the hem cannot be "short" if there is no skirt.
- **Knit (3/4):** Frames 17, 19, 20 show raised cable texture. Frame 18's texture is a pebbled/scale pattern rather than cable, so NO.

**Likely prompt-level fixes required:** strengthen the braid descriptor (thick, single, tied, hanging down back) and add explicit negative for thin/wispy braids; replace the below-waist garment language with unambiguous skirt phrasing plus negatives for shorts/leggings/crotch seam; and consider a camera angle or phrasing change that makes the point of insertion visible rather than occluded.