**Missing context:** The task says images are numbered 09–16, but only **8 images** were supplied with no explicit frame labels. I have assumed the supplied order maps 09→16 sequentially. If the actual frame numbering differs, the pose column (which is frame-dependent) will be wrong.

Also note: the rubric's pose definitions (HELDOPEN = on her back; KNEESUP = knees to chest) do not cleanly match what is visible — several frames appear to be upright/seated rather than supine. I have applied the rubric literally (legs spread wide or knees drawn to chest AND held by hands), not by the stated body orientation.

| frame | hair | pose | legs_held | penetration | skirt | skirt_len | knit | note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 09 | YES | YES | YES | YES | NO | NO | YES | Black shorts topology, crotch seam visible; hem not micro |
| 10 | NO | NO | YES | NO | YES | YES | YES | Braid is thin/wispy; penis mostly occluded at junction |
| 11 | YES | YES | YES | YES | NO | NO | YES | Black shorts with crotch seam, not open hanging fabric |
| 12 | YES | YES | NO | YES | NO | NO | YES | Hands on bed, not gripping her legs |
| 13 | YES | YES | YES | YES | NO | NO | YES | Olive shorts/knickers topology, crotch seam |
| 14 | YES | YES | YES | YES | NO | YES | NO | Bare ass visible; no skirt; knit texture flat/ribbed |
| 15 | YES | YES | YES | YES | NO | NO | YES | Olive shorts topology, crotch seam |
| 16 | YES | NO | YES | YES | YES | YES | YES | Knees up but not drawn to chest; legs not spread wide |

**Totals (YES count / 8):**
- hair: 7 / 8
- pose: 6 / 8
- legs_held: 7 / 8
- penetration: 7 / 8
- skirt: 2 / 8
- skirt_len: 3 / 8
- knit: 7 / 8

**Diagnosis:** The dominant failure is the **skirt** rubric — 6 of 8 frames render shorts/knickers topology (visible crotch seam, leg openings) rather than open hanging skirt fabric. This is a prompt/garment-topology failure, not a per-frame variance: the generator is collapsing "short skirt" into "shorts." Skirt length also fails where the garment is shorts. Secondary issues: one wispy braid (10), one frame with no leg grip (12), and one frame where the knit reads flat rather than chunky cable (14). If the intent is a consistent character sheet, the skirt prompt needs an explicit negative ("no shorts, no crotch seam, open hem, single hanging panel") and the braid needs a thickness qualifier.