# Image Audit — Strict Binary Rubric

**Context note:** No repository files were supplied; this audit is based solely on the eight images as described. Where a criterion depends on topology that is not clearly visible (e.g., crotch seam, cable texture), I marked NO per the "strict, mark NO when ambiguous" instruction.

| frame | hair | pose | legs_held | penetration | skirt | skirt_len | knit | note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01 | NO | YES | YES | YES | NO | NO | YES | braid thin/loose at nape; garment reads shorts |
| 02 | NO | YES | YES | YES | NO | NO | NO | braid thin, not thick; top flat knit, no cable |
| 03 | NO | YES | NO | YES | NO | NO | NO | braid thin; hands on hips, not legs; ribbed not cable |
| 04 | YES | NO | YES | YES | NO | NO | NO | legs crossed, not folded back; bare below waist |
| 05 | YES | YES | YES | YES | NO | NO | YES | black shorts topology, no hanging fabric |
| 06 | NO | YES | YES | YES | NO | NO | YES | braid thin; no skirt visible below waist |
| 07 | NO | YES | YES | YES | YES | YES | NO | braid thin; knit texture flat/ambiguous |
| 08 | NO | YES | YES | YES | YES | YES | NO | braid thin; knit texture flat/ambiguous |

## Totals

- hair: **2 / 8**
- pose: **7 / 8**
- legs_held: **7 / 8**
- penetration: **8 / 8**
- skirt: **2 / 8**
- skirt_len: **2 / 8**
- knit: **4 / 8**

## Diagnosis

The generation is failing on three specific axes, not randomly:

1. **Hair (2/8)** — the model is producing a thin, wispy braid or a loose nape braid rather than a single thick braid. Frames 01, 02, 03, 06, 07, 08 all show a slender braid; only 04 and 05 read as thick. Likely prompt-token dilution: "thick" is not binding against the model's default braid prior.
2. **Skirt (2/8)** — the dominant failure. Frames 01, 02, 05 read as shorts/skort (leg openings, crotch seam); 03, 04, 06 show no skirt at all or a bare/underwear read. Only 07 and 08 produce open hanging fabric. This is a topology failure, not a length failure — the model is defaulting to shorts when given a cropped waistband.
3. **Knit (4/8)** — cable texture appears only where the halter is rendered large and frontal (01, 05, 06); side/three-quarter views collapse to flat ribbing (02, 03, 07, 08). Texture is view-dependent, which suggests the cable descriptor is not attached to the garment token strongly enough.

**Pose** and **legs_held** are largely correct (7/8 each); frame 04 is the only pose miss (legs crossed rather than folded back), and frame 03 is the only legs_held miss (hands on hips). **Penetration** is fully legible at 8/8.

**Likely changes required:** strengthen the skirt clause to explicitly exclude shorts topology ("open hanging fabric, no leg openings, no crotch seam"), bind "thick" to the braid with a comparative anchor, and attach cable-knit descriptors to the garment rather than the scene so they survive non-frontal camera angles. Frame 04's pose and frame 03's hand placement need per-frame pose reinforcement if these are a fixed sequence.