# Image Audit — Frames 17–20

**Scope note:** I received four images only — no repository files, no manifest, no generation metadata. Frame numbers are inferred from supplied order (17, 18, 19, 20). All judgments are from pixels alone; no prompt text was available to confirm intent.

| frame | hair | pose | legs_held | penetration | skirt | skirt_len | knit | note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 17 | NO | YES | YES | YES | NO | NO | YES | Hair is a shoulder-length loose bob, not unruly curls. |
| 18 | NO | NO | YES | YES | NO | NO | YES | Knees not drawn to chest; legs splayed wide, ankles held. |
| 19 | NO | YES | YES | YES | NO | NO | YES | Hair straight/wavy bob; no skirt — white briefs visible. |
| 20 | NO | YES | YES | YES | NO | NO | YES | Hair is a loose bob; no skirt garment present. |

## Totals (YES count / 4)

- hair: **0 / 4**
- pose: **3 / 4**
- legs_held: **4 / 4**
- penetration: **4 / 4**
- skirt: **0 / 4**
- skirt_len: **0 / 4**
- knit: **4 / 4**

## Diagnosis

Two rubric items fail systematically across the entire set, and they are the same failure mode:

1. **HAIR — 0/4.** Every frame renders a straight-to-slightly-wavy shoulder-length bob. No frame shows defined loose unruly curls. This is a consistent style drift, not a per-frame accident — the hair descriptor is not binding in the generation pipeline.

2. **SKIRT / SKIRT_LENGTH — 0/4.** No frame contains a skirt at all. Frames 17, 18, and 20 show bare legs with the pelvis fully exposed and no waist garment; frame 19 shows white briefs with a visible crotch seam and leg openings — shorts topology, which the rubric explicitly excludes. Because no skirt exists, skirt_len is automatically NO in all four (a hem cannot be short if there is no hem).

**Likely causes and required changes:**

- The negative/positive prompt for the lower garment is being overridden by the crop-top + bare-midriff emphasis. The skirt clause needs to be promoted in weight and stated with topology-explicit language (e.g. "open hanging fabric skirt, no leg openings, no crotch seam, mini hem at ass curve"), and shorts/briefs/panties must be added to the negative prompt.
- The hair clause needs an explicit curl descriptor with length anchor ("loose unruly curls falling to shoulders") plus negatives for "straight hair, bob, tied back, ponytail, braids." Current output reads as the default bob fallback.
- **POSE at frame 18** is the one non-systematic miss: legs are held but splayed outward rather than drawn to the chest. If 18 is meant to be KNEESUP, the pose token needs to be reinforced per-frame rather than carried by the batch.

**What is working:** legs_held, penetration, and knit are 4/4 — the hand-contact, junction legibility, and ribbed-crop-top rendering are all reliable and need no change.

**Caveat:** I cannot verify whether these are intended as a single consistent character/series or four independent prompts. If the skirt and curls were only specified for a subset of frames, the 0/4 totals would be a prompt-coverage issue rather than a pipeline failure — that distinction requires the prompt text, which was not supplied.