## Diagnosis

Rubric applied strictly to frames 17–20 (supplied in order). Ambiguous reads marked NO.

| frame | hair | pose | legs_held | penetration | skirt | skirt_len | knit | note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 17 | YES | YES | YES | YES | YES | YES | YES | — |
| 18 | YES | YES | YES | YES | NO | NO | NO | Bare ass, no skirt fabric visible below waist |
| 19 | YES | YES | YES | YES | YES | YES | YES | — |
| 20 | YES | YES | YES | YES | NO | NO | NO | No skirt garment present; knit bandeau only |

**Totals (YES count / 4):**
- hair: 4 / 4
- pose: 4 / 4
- legs_held: 4 / 4
- penetration: 4 / 4
- skirt: 2 / 4
- skirt_len: 2 / 4
- knit: 3 / 4

### Notes on the strict calls

- **Frame 18 — skirt/skirt_len:** The red garment ends at the bandeau; below the waist the figure is bare to the bed. No hanging fabric, so both SKIRT and SKIRT LENGTH fail. (The red bed cover is not a garment.)
- **Frame 18 — knit:** The bandeau reads as a smooth ribbed/banded tube with buttons, not raised cable texture. Marked NO on ambiguity.
- **Frame 20 — skirt/skirt_len:** Same failure mode as 18 — no skirt topology below the waist; the knit bandeau is the only garment. Both columns NO.
- **Frame 20 — knit:** Cable/braid-like raised texture is present and legible, so YES despite the missing skirt.
- **Frame 19 — skirt:** The bunched red knit at the hips reads as open hanging fabric with no leg openings or crotch seam, so YES; hem sits at the ass curve, so skirt_len YES.
- **Frame 17 — skirt:** Red fabric with a black waistband, open below, hem at the ass curve — YES on both.

### Likely fixes required (generation-side, not repo-side)

1. **Skirt persistence:** frames 18 and 20 dropped the skirt entirely — the prompt/conditioning for the lower garment is not surviving the HELDOPEN pose. Needs a stronger, position-independent garment clause (e.g. explicit "short skirt bunched at hips, fabric visible between/around thighs") and possibly per-frame garment reinforcement in the conditioning.
2. **Knit consistency:** frame 18's bandeau lost the cable texture and gained buttons; the knit descriptor needs to be pinned harder or the button/zip detail removed from the prompt.
3. **Pose/legs/penetration are solid across all four** — no action needed there; the failure is isolated to wardrobe.

No files were supplied, so this is an image-level audit only; no repository claims are made.