## Audit — frames 17–20 (strict binary)

| frame | hair | pose | legs_held | penetration | skirt | skirt_len | knit | note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 17 | YES | YES | YES | YES | NO | NO | YES | White knit top ends in a band; below waist is bare, no skirt. |
| 18 | YES | YES | YES | YES | NO | NO | YES | Ribbed band at waist reads as shorts/underwear, not skirt. |
| 19 | YES | YES | YES | YES | NO | NO | YES | Same knit band; no hanging fabric, no hem. |
| 20 | YES | NO | YES | YES | NO | NO | YES | Legs splayed wide and low, not folded back over shoulders. |

**Totals (YES count / 4):**
- hair: 4 / 4
- pose: 3 / 4
- legs_held: 4 / 4
- penetration: 4 / 4
- skirt: 0 / 4
- skirt_len: 0 / 4
- knit: 4 / 4

### Diagnosis

**Systematic failure: the skirt.** All four frames render a ribbed knit *band* at the waist — visually a cropped tube top / boyshort waistband — with bare skin from hip to thigh and no hanging fabric, no hem line, no leg openings to speak of. Frames 18–20 make this explicit: the band terminates at the hip crease and the pelvis is fully exposed. This is not a length problem; it is a *garment identity* problem. `skirt_len` is therefore vacuously NO in all four — you cannot grade a hem that does not exist. Treat these two columns as one defect, not two.

**Pose drift in frame 20.** 17–19 hold the pinned configuration (on back, knees folded up and out, feet near shoulders). Frame 20 collapses into a wide splayed V with legs extended low and feet flat on the bed — closer to a butterfly/straddle than a pin. Strict rubric says NO.

**What is working.** Hair (two high tails, ribbon/ties present in all four), leg manipulation (hands on knees/thighs in every frame), penetration legibility, and the halter knit with raised rib/cable texture are all consistently correct. The knit is the strongest element — frames 19–20 even carry a cable-knit variant, which exceeds the "ribbed" spec.

**Likely fixes, in priority order:**
1. Prompt the lower garment as an explicit noun with physical properties — "short pleated skirt," "mini skirt with visible hem," "fabric hanging from waistband, no crotch seam" — and *negatively* prompt "shorts, boyshorts, underwear, waistband, tube top." The current wording appears to be losing to the knit-top token and collapsing into a matching crop band.
2. Separate skirt and top into distinct garment clauses with different materials/colors so the model cannot merge them.
3. For frame 20, re-assert the pin in the pose clause ("both knees folded back beside her head, held") and consider a negative for "legs spread wide, feet flat."
4. If the skirt is a hard requirement across the set, expect a re-roll of all four — 0/4 is not a near-miss, it is a missing element.